Tristan McIntosh “Good Girl” “American Idol” Video: Watch Top 24 Performance!

Truth rating: 10
Tristan McIntosh Good Girl American Idol Video

By Shari Weiss |

Tristan McIntosh Good Girl American Idol Video


Tristan McIntosh covered Carrie Underwood on “American Idol” on Wednesday. Watch below!

As Gossip Cop reported, the Top 24 for the “farewell season” was announced earlier this month. The remaining contestants were then broken into two groups of 12. The first group performed last week, with seven making it into the Top 14 and five eliminated.

Now it was McIntosh’s group’s turn to perform for the judges in front of a packed house at the Vibiana in Los Angeles. And the teen tried to make a strong case for why she should be one of the seven to advance this week. Taking on Underwood’s “Good Girl,” she showed a new spicy side of herself, despite her young age.

The results, though, were mixed. Jennifer Lopez told McIntosh, “The end felt like you were feeling more, and that’s when it got good.” Harry Connick, Jr. said, “You’re super-talented. The good news is I heard you do something I haven’t heard you do before, which is sing loud, so congratulations on that.”

And Keith Urban said, “You have so much talent, and you look like a million bucks. You really do.” But was it the right song and a finale-worthy performance? The panel wasn’t so sure. Check out the video below.


  1. Gossip Cop
  2. Mediaite
  3. LawNewz
  4. The Mary Sue