American Idol American Idol new judge American Idol new judges Elton John Elton John new judge Justin Timberlake Justin Timberlake new judge Kara DioGuardi Simon Cowell

July 27th, 2010

Here’s a shocker: HollywoodLife saw big names in a rumor and printed it without checking for accuracy.

“Fox executives have been in talks to replace the current ["American Idol"] judges with superstars like Elton John and Justin Timberlake,” writes the site, sourcing very speculative reports that suggested John and Timberlake could be in the mix to replace Simon Cowell.

3 comments