comScore
  1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough
  8. The Braiser

Busting bad dish!

Selena Gomez Named in $1 Million Lawsuit; Band Claims She Ripped Off Song

LISTEN

(GettyImages.com)

Selena Gomez has been named in a $1 million lawsuit that claims her 2010 hit “A Year Without Rain” features a chorus that’s “virtually identical” to the band Luce’s 2005 track “Buy A Dog.”

The plaintiffs are four songwriters — Tom Luce, Brian Kroll, Matt Blackett and Lawrence Riggs — who allege that Gomez and her band (The Scene) lifted the Luce song’s chorus for “A Year Without Rain,” which became the title track of Gomez’s second studio album.

LISTEN TO BOTH SONGS BELOW

The credited co-writers behind Gomez’s hit, Lindy Robbins and Toby Gad, have also been named co-defendants.

According to Courthouse News Service, Luce says that “Buy A Dog” had enormous airplay on Sirius/XM radio and other outlets in 2005, and that “the melodies in the chorus of both songs are virtually identical.”

The plaintiffs declare that Gomez and her co-defendants are infringing on their copyright.

Take a listen to the two tracks and let us know what you think.

Follow @GossipCop on Twitter!

Like us on Facebook!

“Buy A Dog”:

“A Year Without Rain”:

You might like:


  • Anonymous

    So they’re suing for her song having a similar type melody to the chorus? It’s not the same lyrics or music, but a similar melody. Might as well sue other artists for doing the same thing, it’s not like you can mistake one song for the other. I had to listen twice because I didn’t hear it at first.

  • Guest

    I can sort of see it, but I wouldn’t have even noticed the similarity if I hadn’t been looking for it. I don’t really get what the big deal is, a lot of songs have similar melodies in spots. I personally don’t think this is law-suit worthy.

  • Team Selena

    So stupid. She didn’t rip them off. Her song is better & they just want to cash in off of her because their song wasn’t popular. Get a life people. Do you know how many songs in this world sound similar now at some point with the music?? Get over it.

  • Yudgreen

    EVEN THE MELODY IS DIFFRENT. THE RHTAM OF THE SONGS SO DIFFRENT YOU CAN’T EVEN HEAR IT. YOU NEED TO RELLY LOOK FOR IT. ALL POP SONG ARE A BIT SIMELR ON MELODY. THEY JUST WANT TO GET FAMOUS FROM THE BUZZ THEY KNEW THIS LAWSUIT HAS NO BASE.

  • Lindsey

    Sounds pretty similar to me.

  • Regina1180

    Even if they sound nothing alike, now the band has more YouTube hits.

  • wrong

    and thats what they wanted

  • http://twitter.com/BluButterfly14 Lena Martinovic

    it does sound similar, but please… I can name you another dozen of songs that have the melody without listening to them first.

  • Ahahha

    enormous airplay in 2005? says who?
    they are just looking for attention and a cash grab from Selena

    most of them fail like Mariah yeater wanting money from Selena’s boyfriend Justin but SHE FAILED

  • Ahahha

    HATE to break it to you but the world does not revolve around you

    selena’s song : the melody/chorus is not the same so why the hell would you sue her when it’s not a copyright infringement? i can call him dumb for that

  • A Selena fan

    It’s so messed I would not have known if i was not looking for it they just want money from Selena they should jut leave her alone they will fail they will not get her money.

  • Ahahha

    They should just say thank selena geez

  • Ahahha

    They should just thank selena geez

  • Anonymous

    just as Dawn replied I’m taken by surprise that a person able to get paid $8937 in 1 month on the computer. have you read this link http://tomakeusd.blogspot.in/

  • Kait

    I can kind of hear it . . . it’s in a different key, so it’s hard to distinguish. but even though the melody is similar, the chords are different making the choruses sound quite disimilar. curiously, i wonder if the band paid royalties to the animation companies hanna barbara and whoever owns snoopy these days?? as well as to each person whose youtube video they used?? because i would HATE for that to come back and smack them in the face if it gets all the way to court . . .

  • Faridaselena92

    that band is full of shit, they should get a life, SELENA GOMEZ AND THE SCENE write their own music. and i didnt hear anything alike.

  • mark

    to me it is so simple.. this band wants some free press being that selena gomez is an excellent singer/songwriter and makes good music/hit songs while that’s group’s song is prolly their one and only hit.. this is a frivolous lawsuit and will be thrown out soon enough.. selena gomez need not worry

  • MOM OF OLD SKOOL

    hello ace of base and gaga Madonna and gaga Selena and this band no … but close

  • Dont_stop_me_now

    selena dont even wrote her songs

  • Jailyn

    Personally I would never have picked up that they sound similar if i hadn’t listen to them side by side, pausing each song and referring to each of them. I have never heard “buy a dog” before but that could be because I am out of America. It doesn’t sound as close as other songs like Lady Gaga’s born this way and Madonna’s express yourself

  • Brett

    Her damn song sucks ass. All her music autotune anyways yall little girls need help if u can her music real.

  • John

    Get famous of who? Selena? Ha the same chick of has increased fame thanx to copying other people as well not just them.

  • David

    Selenas boyfriend? Ha no shes more like HIS girlfriend. And selena uses HIS money as well so…

  • JAy

    Kid, selenas only worth 4 million in hollywood that aint shit. Who could possibly gie a damn about her money? Noone

  • Brett

    Exactly she never has.

  • Brett

    That made no sense

  • Magaret

    Correction selena isnt a songwriter. She writes NONE of her music and has -admitted that herself. And singer? She cant even hold a note without autotune. She wouldnt last two seconds on american idol or the voice. The main reason her music is popular now comes from publicity of er obvipus “relationship” im an. Adult with two daughters and i know this. They wouldnt even be talkig about her if she was not dating bieber.

  • Brett

    Actially shes said herself she doesnt write her own music. So…

  • Jermey

    For what? Thank her for what? Shea talentless.

  • Ahahha

    your english sucks

  • Anonymous

    I don’t think people in America have heard this song before this article. I know I haven’t lol

  • Brett

    How does my english suck when i am american dumbass. If u wanna speak on someone make a valid statement.

  • Ahahha

    dumbass prick

  • David b conway

    dear gossip cop web site , hi my name is david conway and my comments to here is that who ever is putting a lawsuit on selena gomez , i just what to say just from me why did they waited this long just by putting a lawsuit on selena gomez all this time may i ask , just because of there own album failed just by them , they should go to jail them self , i do know more about law , just if the second party doesn,t have any prooff at all they will be sitting in jail ,love david b conway

  • http://twitter.com/DonaldFutral Donald Futral

    they’re just mad because unlike their song selena’s is actually worth listening 2

  • Ann

    Selenas song is shit and fully of autotune. Ck ur facts

  • Lucy

    it’s a matter of integrity. she probably didn’t know, but what they claim is very valid. they have the right to claim what’s theirs, and this case can only be resolved with money. it’s not like they can take down her song, so… even if you’re fans of her, you should be more respectful to other people’s work.

  • Arcachnar

    Wait. This ‘known’ band (yeah-right) claim that they made this song in 2005. “A Year Without Rain” was in 2010 a major hit. Why waiting until now? Sounds like they want to be over Selena’s back in the spotlight again. Sorry, Luce. Goodbye.

  • Matt

    Hit? Lmaooooooo OK.

  • Brett

    The prick is clealry you commenting ignorantly jumping into a convo that you were not jn with an invalid ass statement like the one you made. Clap back.

  • Arcachnar

    Yes. It was a big hit. Have you ever heard of Luce? No? Their song ‘Buy a Dog’ was only was the most played song on at least 13 radio stations. But did you ever heard of this band and their song? No.

    And I quote: Propelled by its debut at number fourteen on the Hot Digital Songs chart, “A Year Without Rain” debuted at number thirty-five on the Billboard Hot 100, becoming the group’s third consecutive top forty single.[13] It remained on the chart for four weeks.[13] On the week dated January 1, 2011, the song debuted at number thirty-six on the US Hot Dance Club Play chart.[14] It achieved greater success in Canada, peaking at thirty on the Canadian Hot 100.[15] The song appeared on numerous European charts, peaking at seventy-eight in the United Kingdom,[16] fifty-six in Germany,[17] and forty-one in Slovakia.[18] It also reached number three on the Belgian Flanders Tip chart.[19]

  • Shauna Cardwell

    Personal i dont think it sounds the same, whats the big deal its just a song at the end of the day the world aint gonna end! :)

  • Ahahha

    yeah the prick is you

    now go back to school and learn some english

  • Matt

    Awkward moment when i actually knew of them before i even heard that gomez girls music. So unless you know me, to say what i havent heard makes you look stupid as hell.

  • Melissa

    Omg that dude is crazy. Ignore him. Anything selena gez related that kid comments and get mad when someone doesnt like her ass. Its hilariously pathetic. She wouldnt have not one “hit” if it wasnt for disney signing her which happens to all their people, if it werent for autotune, the band backing her up, her backup singers, and jelena marvelous raid of publicity her way for dating THE JUSTIN BIEBER. if it werent for jelena happening they wouldnt even tale the time to do an article about her and thats a fact.

  • Matt

    Yeah i know. The girl doesnt even write her own songs. It was bound to happen. She even copied cheryls’s tour outfits to the T. And had them as “her tour outfits” even her fragrance idea is referbished from others. She wouldnt have even thought to hae a frgrance is justin and taylor hadnt created one. The purple theme she got was based off justins and the red kissed lips on the bottlw dont even match. Even her funny or die video was not made till after justin dis his. The girl seriously doesnt have an original bone in her body. Someone needs to tell her to be herself for once. She even copies others is regular wear. Even her tcs outfit was taken from
    Mileys yet miley got hate for hers but when she wore it, it was cute? Smh its a mess.

  • cgmar11

    They are similar sounding, but not enough for a lawsuit. I can’t tell you how many songs sounds similar to one another. I’m pretty sure the band’s not going to get any money out of this.

    And shame on them for telling us to buy a dog instead of adopt.

  • Arcachnar

    @Matt Sure. You suddenly know them. Yeah right.

    @Melissa If it was about Justin, you will clearly defend him, right? Stop being a hypocrite. Besides, he was very lucky. Only through the help from Scooter, Usher and a lot of commerce’s made him famous. So. He could not do this on his own.

    Selena, Miley, Demi Lovato, John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Michael, Michael Jackson, Johnny Cash, Prince, Iggy Pop, John Denver, Freddie Mercury, et al. did this on their own. I’m a really great fan of ALL of them.

    I love country, Death Metal, Rock, a bit of pop and old-school hiphop.

  • Matt

    Lol that fool is trying to tell me who the hell i got damn dont know. This bitch really wants to get told off lol

  • Melissa

    Just ignore him. He is dumb.

  • Brett

    How is prick me when your dumbass came out the blue commenting? Noone was talking to you. And learn english? Haha! Dumbass are you seriously this dumb or what? I have not made not ONE error. So looks like not only do you have no validation to what youre saying but youre showing just what a got damn idiot YOU ARE. Only prick is you and clearly judging from your writing the one who needs to go back to school to learn how to Learn english is you. Im american dumbass i know english better than you ever will and my degree so sit your idiotic ass down. Stop embarassing yourself. Freak.

  • Anonymous

    They are very similar so I can see why the band is filing a lawsuit. The biggest difference is I like the Luce song and dislike the Selena song.

  • Arcachnar

    Wow. Melissa. The only one who is dumb is YOU. Who else would say something THAT stupid? I was trying to make you understand something, but you are clearly just a troll.

    Did you ever said something constructive here on ALL the threads of GC? No. Just trolling.

    @Matt. Perhaps you know them, but you know that it sounds a bit too coincidence to me.

  • Arcachnar

    I have not heard the other one. Some problems with the video. So. I cannot judge. Yet. But. Why are they waiting until now? Shouldn’t they done this back in 2010?

  • Hey

    It’s honestly funny how people are claiming that Selena only got her success from dating Justin when in reality the only things that she has gotten from dating him are hate and death threats. Selena is as popular as she is today because of the success from her latest albumn and movies. I think a lot of people forget the fact that Selena was staring in a two time Emmy award winning television show back when barely anyone even knew who Justin was. Selena does not win awards and have millions of fans because of him so how is her success dependent on him? And as far as this whole lawsuit goes; the only similarity that I heard in the song was the first line of the chorus, but other than that I heard no other similarities.

  • Kayinmcn

    What exactly is autotune? I don’t think I’ve ever heard of that.

  • Arcachnar

    Amen. Totally agree with you.

  • Carl

    This comment is so hilariously invalid its pathetic.

  • Melissa

    @Matt told you the fool would come back to comment. Funny how he says what I said was stupid yet he made over two grammatical errors in his one middle schooler statement and states what i said was stupid when he clearly wasnt. Anyone that uses the term “troll” is the “troll” themselves and the epitome of ignorance. The fact hes trying to tell YOU what music YOU listen to. Then claim hes trying to tell US SOMETHING? ha! He cant tell us a damn thing. This kids needs help. The ONLY post he EVER comments on is “selena gomez” and “bieber” related. Clearly hes too busy obsessing over a girl he will never have a chance with to come up for air to realize we sont cate what he thinks.

  • Gina

    LOL! times are so tough now that people are suing each other because of sound similarity in music?! fucking pathetic! welcome to america everyone!

  • Melissa

    @Matt see! Told you the fool would come back to comment. Funny how he says that what i said was stupid yet he made over two grammatical errors in His one immature statement alone to state what i said was invalid when it clearly wasnt. Anyone who uses to term “troll” is a “troll” themselves and lets me know their true age. He is the epitome of ignorance. The fact hes calling me a troll yet can see me, doesnt know me and trolls this damn site like hes someones fucking parent commenting on what EVERYONE says tells us all we need to know about him. The fact hes trying to tell YOU what music YOU listen to is dumb as hell. He claims hes trying to tell us something. Ha! What exactly? How he cant respect anyones opinion? He cant tell us a damn thing. This kid is seriously mental. He inly conments post “selena gomez” and “bieber” related. Clearly hes a obsessed boy fan of her wishing he had a shot to come up for to realize we dont care what he thinks.

  • Melvin

    How exactly is it “america” youre dumb.

  • Matt

    I couldnt agree more.

  • Tish

    As a mother of three. I DO NOT agree with that person above at all. All tm kids watch disney channel and hated her show. I have not ice hear nor see her on gossipcop at all till now that shes dating justin bieber. No matter what people say noone can deny te fact he has upped her fame in a huge way and alot of opportunites, awards, and pther things have been given to her aimply because of it. Living ere in la since my youth and interning at records companies as a young girl taught me alot and that one thing is. THIS IS HOLLYWOOD. They dont gove a damn about what “talent” you supposedly have. Tey only care about money, publicity, selling, and making money in any way shape or form. And i see publicity all over this “jelena” relationship . Even google dis a report recently on her search statistics since she started dating each and every star and now THE justin bieber has set her in a new avenue and only a blind person would deny it.

  • Arcachnar

    Wow. Another trolling attempt and not even constructive. As usually. Why do not you ever learn? Let me break it down to you. Nice and simple:

    1) Do not point out others grammatical errors, when your own spelling and grammar is not great either. English is my THIRD language, what’s your excuse?

    2) Yes. You are acting stupid, like a middle schooler and immature. Yes. Typically trolling.

    3) I never said to Matt which music he should like. I was pointing out which kind I like.

    Death Metal, Country, Rock, some pop and old-school hiphop. Awesome music. Do not care which music he likes. Read before posting.

    4) When do you begin to understand that I’m just a regular fan of her? No obsession. I really hate the fucking half truths and lies. Just like they have done with the others that I like.

    5) You should have noticed that I post not exclusive about Selena, but about others as well. Demi, Miley, Paul McCartney (Beatles and Wings), Gibbs from the Beegees, et al. I’m having a long list of idols that I like.

    Which music do you like?

  • Arcachnar

    Wow. You just copied your own post. How mature. Clearly, you really have nothing better to say. Like I said, you are just trolling for attention.

    Oh. I’m posting on the threads that is not about Selena as well. That’s a lot. Unlike yours, are all my posts constructive and on topic. You ONLY post when Selena and/or Justin are mentioned.

    Saying that I’m trolling GC is pathetic. Because you are the only troll here.

  • David

    You ge mad when someone says YOU are “trolling” which is even a damn word yet you can call someone you dont even know one. She owned your ass kiddo. Stop embarrassing youraelf. Go find a selena poster to lick.

  • Melissa

    Haha exactl hes a complete idiot. He copied everythig i said. Saying i only comment when justin and selena are involved yet im not fans of either and this is my first time ever commenting to a post. All the other times i just read the comments. BIG FAIL FOR HIM. Clearly HE is the one with nothig to say and the dumbass at that saying he supplies “constructive” comments yet look at the comment above. His own comments make him look like a nut case. Hes pathetic pn here desperate for attention HIMSELF mad because he has no real friend to talk to. And hea lying cause i alwas read gossipcop and e pnly has commented bieber and selena related stuff i even can pull up the post myself. Any pther post about pther stars you never see his ugly ass name on. He is the one pathetic. Just sweep him to the side. And dot let him bother you. We can say what we want. Fuck him.

  • David

    True. True. True. I read what he said ad was like… Um… Is this dude for real? He seriously not clicking at the top. Im deinitely ignoring him you do the same. Thats why youngsters should never be allowed online.

  • Khoshy

    Hae to jump in Couldnt agree more. Its sad how ppl get mad just cause someone doesnt think and operate the way they want. Children. He commented on a post i was in once literally commenting everything people said. It was annoying.

  • Melissa

    Did anyone read shit this dumbass says? Nope. This guy is such a joke. Im not even going to waste my time owning him again.

  • Matt

    Yea dont. I would comment but with a moron like this its like talking to a brick wall.

  • Melissa

    Amen!!!!!

  • Joyce

    I remember you from the other articles. Haha… You and anna. I agree with you and tish. I dont know why any of this is even an argument. Noone gives a shit about that girl. Lol

  • Arcachnar

    All tm kids? Huh? What do you mean?

    There are just a lot more rumors about Justin than about Selena.

    Justin did nothing for her in the trend of awards, opportunities, et al. Only for himself. He has not got that great influence on others. Even though, he thinks it sometimes. He only gave her fans who sends death threats and unwanted publicity by the paps.

  • Arcachnar

    Wow. Desperate for more attention, right?

    1) I do not know where you get the impression that I’m copying you? I never did. On the other hand, you began to copy your own post. And I pointed that out to you. Don’t you have better things to do?

    2) @David Wow. She owns me? Haha. Don’t make me laugh. I know. You are just bandwagon.

    3) ‘owned me again’ Wow. How cute. Your flames or ‘arguments’ are pathetically immature. And you just copied your own post with the same lame flame. You will NEVER own anyone with this kind of childish behavior. Nobody need to flame you, because you just already making a fool of yourself.

    4) You must have overlooked the fact that I posted in the threads about Demi, Miley, Paul McCartney, Kim K. Once about Justin and Whitney Houston. Go and check.

    5) Perhaps you are new. Sorry. But. You sound familiar.

  • Arcachnar

    Auto tune is a program that correct some faults in the singing on someone’s record. Everyone uses it. From Michael Jackson to Justin Bieber.

  • Vanessa

    why are people even wasting their time tryin to cuss everyone else out?! this is just some bullshit that hollywood does. c’mon its hollywood for cryin out loud! get over it…

  • Tish

    ^^^^^^ see this dude. Perfect example of the blind i was referring to. I had no clue people can be this stupid.

  • Exselenafan

    He said justin has caused selena death threats yet that was so petty shit that was A JOKE over a year ago. People were sending them on purpose because they knew the media would act that way and those twitters dont even exist anymore. Selena brings hate on herself. EVERY celeb ets hate she is NO exception. Un wanted publicity? Ha all the publicity shes had shes wanted and asked for. Dont like it? Leave the industry. Justin bieber is in FACT. along with lady gaga the top teo most influential celebs on twitter. So sit and say isnt when uts proven he is, is dumb. And the fact that melissa girl who commented below saying how e comments everything. You are absolutely right because clearly tish you werent talking to him making a comment on tour own and looks what he does. He called herthe troll yet hes trolling. How ironic. He did EVERYTHING for her refent awards and the awards shows own representatives admitted that themselves via twitter long ago. Its not a damn mystery. Its a current fact that she herself is even aware of and has made that clear on tumblr and interviews. If she werent dating justin bieber theres no way in hell she would have won the recent awardsshes required which were based on popularity and she sure as hell wouldnt have never been presented with the idea to host that awards show. She would be irrelevant to the media entirely. They say “justin hiebers girlfriend” for a reason. Noone cares about her all they care about it getting the “jelena” inside scoop. Even her OWN fans knows this and have talked about it on twitter numorous times. Im an ex fan of hers. For reasons ive actually met her and she was nothing far from a complete brat. So I definitely have a reason and facts behind everything i know. I ran one of the top most popular selena gomez sites on twitter. Im her same age as have been neck deep in the real fanbase. Not sitting on blogs reading stuff like this guy does on the surface not knowing shit. Ive been apart of all the real drama and can name countless fans who have BLOCKED yes BLOCKED selena on twitter. She was following them they were huge fans they find out how she really is and they blocked her. Even her own fans know the surplus amount of fame shes been given just by who she dates and arent stuck in denial. So to keep bringing up the ” death threat” crap is beyond old. People need to get over it pack up and move on. And i know hes gonna fulfill his argumentative urge and comment below but i dont care. My opinion isnt changing nor wavering. U dont care what he says and im sure noone else does either. End of.

  • Melissa

    Exactly. This archanar dude is the only one all hype commenting everythjng for arguments like anyones reading what he says. Noone cares about this publicity loving tennie booper. Let her ass get sued. Her 4 million worth has been gone long ago anyways.

  • Exselenafan

    Touche. There are disney stars who dont work as much as selena “claims” to yet they make more than she does. All those “awards” ad success yet thats all shes worth. *shakes head*

  • Melissa

    Exactly!!!! Even that emily osmet girl is worth a point more than her. I dont see why any of these bubble gum pop stars are even big. She wouldnt last a round in american idol or the voice. I can pick over 100 yourube artist who can make them look like yesterdays trash.

  • Exselenafan

    I agree with that 120% theres this girl neon hitch i was looking at the other day. Shes amazing. Im glad my faze of hers is over. It took her blowing me and 5 fans ourside her tour bus off the realize her true side. I have nothing for her anymore and i know many other selena fans who are next in line behind me.

  • Melissa

    Well they are smart. Then. As are you. Congrats on seeing the light haha

  • Briannabelieber

    The only one who can sing from disney is miley, demi, hilary, raven, that girl from evan stevens whi played the sister, china mclean, and the high school musical people, oh! And chelsea from thas so raven. To me selena cant sing at all. I tried listening to her music but i couldnt take the ear pain.

  • Briannabelieber

    Demi is worth more too. But of course he is her new records are topping the charts. Her voice is amazing! And then too thats not even wat rhey have in the bank its more like what they totally grosses earned since theyve been in the industry. Selenas been in the industry so long supposedly but people like justin have surpassed her in every way shape and form in just three years.

  • Melissa

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ this

  • Melissa

    This ^^^^^

  • Brett
  • Compucomer

    The chorus for both songs are very similar. It looks like the band Luce has a good case. I actually like the song ” Buy a dog” better anyway.

  • David b conway

    dear web site , hi my name is david conway and my comments to here i just hope your pepole here can just read my comment and to reply to it as well, i just discovered the illale word just to this issue and to this lawsuit , it,s called , fruad and yes there getting money off it , love david b conway

  • David b conway

    dear gossip cop web site , hi my name is david conway and my comments to here is that im not a pervert just like you , why do you lick that poster yourself , the only reason why i am here just to beinging with by talking about this lawsuit and you , and i do just feel like this smale and the lawsuit they just what there own publiciy act just for them and money , love david b conway

  • David b conway

    i do feel like selena gomez , is going to win this lawsuit just because i do know some of the state law in music and motion pictures and by making copying,s of them and by seling them of there own versision that is so illgale in the state , and that is called fraud , love david b conway

  • David b conway

    just by making copy,s of some one,s music or there motion picture on video or dvd fbi warring lable is called a fraud in the fedral copying law , love david b conway

  • Arcachnar

    GC really should do something about the reply buttons.

    Chelsea? Her actual name is Annelies Van Der Pol.

    Hillary Duff? I cannot remember some of her songs, because it had been years ago that I heard something from her.

    Raven? That has been years ago that I heard her sing with the Cheetah Girls. So. I cannot remember as well.

    Miley? Yeah. Good singer. I like her songs, but not all her Hannah Montana songs.

    Demi? Awesome. She is the best singer of them all. I love her old and new songs. That is my favorite star. Love her songs and personality.

    Selena? She is not originally a singer. So. That is why she is not that good in singing like Demi. Love Who says and A Year without Rain. Also, love her personality and her acting. But that is my opinion.

    HM? Only Vanessa and Ashley Tisdale sang real. Someone else did it for Zack. Others? I have no idea. Probably not.

    Emily Osment? Yes. I was surprised of her singing skills.

    Me? I am fan of all of them. Except Raven and Vanessa.

  • Arcachnar

    Huh? Y’all (that is the right spelling) commented on my post. I only came here to comment about the fact that’s rather strange that this band Luce waited THAT long to sue them. Nothing more. Nothing less.

    But seriously. Do not you find it too coincidence? Now that this band is in a lot of trouble? Sounds suspicious to me.

  • Rachell

    Actually she co wrote one on her first album, it’s called “I won’t apologize”

  • Wolfazura

    Luce is much better than this crappy 21st century singer “Selena Gomez”. I dislike her music. But their is choruses are alike. And I hate when people rip off eachother’s music. So I agree. Luce has every right to sue this uneducated girl of the copyright bisness. Sorry honey, (and the writers of this song a year without rain), smarten up.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/4YHUYAUI5WJPUHPEEWDIGLPIBQ Aaliyah

    I hear it..i really do..but you have to really look for it. Its in the chorus and its the melody…Also..she doesnt write her own songs and she said it her self. Why would they want money off of her anyway…she’s talentless..she can sing a little but she should stick to acting..Altough..luce does sound better that selena…the writers should be more careful when writing songs..

  • http://twitter.com/Georgechar sel gomez fan

    what about pitbull with let it rain over me???? NOW THAT’S A REAL COPYCAT!!!!!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/chris.digmann Chris Digmann

    They sound nothing alike. Oh and selena gomez didn’t copy from anyone

  • SelenaGomezRocksMySocksOff

    Luce is just jealous because their song was not as big as hers. Their song was only on Sirius/XM and I have never even heard of them. The only way for them to get noticed is through this negativity. Selena Gomez rocks it on multiple radio stations, television, the big screen and grocery store shopping music.

  • WTF

    You’re entitled to your opinion, but learn some grammar, dude! It just makes you look stupid…

Abrams Media Network click here for advertising opportunities
X