American Idol Results Shocker: Judges Split Leads to Dramatic Elimination

Truth rating: 10

By Shari Weiss



“American Idol” gave another contestant the boot on Thursday’s results show — and it was the most dramatic elimination of the season thus far.


Dexter Roberts, Majesty Rose, and MK Nobilette were all in the Bottom Three, with Nobilette ultimately revealed to be the one in jeopardy of going home.

She performed “All of Me” again in hopes of winning the judges’ only save of the season, as an emotional Jennifer Lopez talked passionately with Harry Connick Jr. and Keith Urban.

Ryan Seacrest urged the panel to come to a decision, and Lopez declined to talk.

Instead, Connick took over and stressed that saving someone has to be a unanimous choice among the three judges — and it wasn’t.

Nobilette, the series’ first openly-gay contestant, was then eliminated.

Of course, the contestant had been in the Bottom Three twice before, but she was sent to safety early on just last week.

Check out the video, plus the list of remaining singers, below, and tell us what you think of the results.

Follow @GossipCop on Twitter!

Like us on Facebook!


Start at 13:30 mark.

TOP 9 of SEASON 13

Alex Preston

Dexter Roberts

Caleb Johnson

Sam Woolf

C.J. Harris

Malaya Watson

Majesty Rose

Jessica Meuse

Jena Irene

Enter your email address here to receive daily news updates from us.


  1. Gossip Cop
  2. Mediaite
  3. RunwayRiot
  4. The Mary Sue