Hmm I would’ve liked to have seen more of the story they left off on, but this sounds cool too. I just hope they don’t lose viewers because of the change because that’s usually what happens when creator change the characters like this.

I probably wont be watching if its done like this. It takes a while to warm up to characters and then by the time the you start to care about them its near the end of the first season. I think it will be hard to accept new characters especially since I liked some of the old ones. I personally think he killed to many of the characters in season one. Not one character had any chance of survival, he should have stopped at Violet, because it started to become very predictable. He killed Characters who really had no need to be killed, like Hayden. She really served no great purpose in dying or even being brought into the series other then an after mention. I enjoyed the show to an extent but would have liked to have seen more thought put into each episode it really felt like there was no plan for the characters, like it was being made up as each episode was written.

They’re def bringing Jessica back, she’s nominated for a Golden Globe. She’ll come back, just probably not as the same character.

NO! all wrong gotta keep the same faces. They wont be as intresting as the original cast, wpnt be watching if this happens.

Dear Ryan Murphy,
No. Bad idea.
Sincerely, me (AHS fan)

I would be okay with using a new set of characters IF the first season had answered all the questions they left in that first arc. It’s stupid and unfair to leave so many unanswered questions, and then start a new season with a completely different story and especially with the same actors playing different characters. That just completely prevents it from being able to cycle back to the original story and answer all those unanswered questions. As someone else said, this is series suicide. I get that they want to be original, but couldn’t they have figured out another way without pissing off so many viewers? I think the SMART thing to do if they wanted to have different characters in every season, is to have the new characters as they wanted in new stories but with NEW actors. Not the old ones! Every season could have a new american horror story with new actors, and then when it’s time for the series to start nearing it’s end, they could bring all those stories together to tie in to the original one so we get all the answers that we were hoping for. But using the same actors as new characters does not allow for that to happen. So, in a word, stupid move.